He says the publication of Go Set a Watchman is a fraud on the reading public.  Here are his points:

1.  Harper Lee is 89, almost blind and deaf, and lives in a nursing home.  Her protective sister died, leaving Tonja Carter as a type of “guardian” for Lee.  Carter announced recently that she’d just “discovered” a new manuscript that Harper Lee had written years ago—which has become Go Set a Watchman.  In fact, Carter knew of the existence of the manuscript as far back as 2011 but as long as Harper Lee’s sister was Lee’s protector, the manuscript never saw the light of day.  Carter took the newly “discovered” manuscript to HarperCollins for publication.

2.  Joe Nocera believes the new book is really the first draft of To Kill a Mockingbird.  The original draft was stuffed into a desk.  Harper Lee never intended that the draft should be published—it’s not very good and wasn’t up to the high standards that Ms. Lee set for her writing.

3.  Ms. Carter and HarperCollins saw a chance to make millions.  They started a huge media campaign months ago and skillfully exploited the public’s yearning to read more from Harper Lee.  Go Set a Watchman has sold 1.1 milliion books already and will undoubtedly sell millions more.  Ultimately, the entire publication was a scam to get the public to buy—if so, it’s working.

After having working in criminal law for over 30 years, I tend to view people in a more cynical way than I did years ago.  I think Nocera is onto something here.  If Harper Lee had wanted this manuscript published, why didn’t she do it during all those years from 1960 (when Mockingbird was publshed) until now?  Go Set a Watchman would have been out to the public years ago.

What do you think?  Has anyone read it?  Some of my friends who have read it say it’s not up to Harper Lee’s standards . . .

The post Go Set a Watchman—Part II appeared first on Colin T. Nelson.

Howell Raines was the former managing editor at the New York Times and has written such heavy tomes as, Fishing Through the Midlife Crisis.  Since I’m a fly fisher, I read his book years ago, before I reached middle age, and was, therefore, fully prepared when it hit.  His solution to a crises was to go fishing—not bad advice for many reasons.

Anyway, he also qualifies, more importantly, as the reviewer of Go Set a Watchman because Raines is from Alabama.  He coined the term, “red-neck Riviera” for the Gulf coast of Florida, Alabama, and Mississippi.  He also is a self-proclaimed red-neck—who has changed and become a progressive.  While not rejecting his history in the south, he apologizes for some of it, has moved on from other parts of it, and is proud to have done so.

He’s qualified to review Harper Lee’s new book since it takes place in time after her famous, To Kill a Mockingbird.  One of the most startling things about the new book, Go Set a Watchman, is the evolution of pure, honest, and unbiased Atticus Finch.  He’s now moved into the 1950’s and is able to give the exact, racist speeches that I heard in the 60’s on TV.

Howell Raines says this is just Harper Lee reflecting on the dismal course of race relations in the south.  She’s recording them in a more brutal and realistic manner in the new book.

I confess that I haven’t read the new book yet.  Will I?  I don’t know.  There’s part of me that has heard so much of the problems from the south regarding racism that I’m tired of hearing it.  It’s like reading about the Holocaust . . .again.  I know what happened, I think, and don’t need to be reminded for the four hundredth time.  Also, what made To Kill a Mockingbird so good was the innocence of the story.  I know it couldn’t be all that good, in reality, but it sure made for a great book!  In my experience, sequels are usually a disappointment, anyway.

Also, I’ll miss the viewpoint of the main character.  In Go Set a Watchman, Scout is an adult and has an adult perception of events in her hometown.  Why is it that so many great, great stories are told from the viewpoint of a child or someone child-like.  Think about Huckleberry Finn or The Old Man and the Sea.  (The hero is a poor, uneducated fisherman who is child-like)

If any of you read it, please let me know what you think of Go Set a Watchman.

The post Go Set a Watchman—How is It? appeared first on Colin T. Nelson.