There’s been a lot of talk lately about our fight against crime and what’s broken. But from someone who’s worked in the courtrooms for 30+ years, I can tell you there are things that are working in our fight against crime.
For years, we’ve assumed that increased penalties can deter criminals and reduce crime. It’s not a new idea, but it took hold in the 1980s and politicians started increasing the prison time for various crimes. Today, we’re looking at the result of these “get tough on crime” statutes. We see that our jails are packed—more than almost any other country in the world. It not only ruins lives (including the families of the inmates when they aren’t supporting their families), but it also costs the taxpayers millions of dollars.
Here’s an recent essay that casts some light on the problem It’s a little long, so hang in there.
http://www.startribune.com/increasing-the-cost-of-crime-doesn-t-make-us-safer/370334841/
The author makes some interesting points:
—He starts by comparing our response to crime to being a parent. When our child misbehaves, we “punish” them by time-outs, staying in their rooms, not being able to play with friends, etc. But at some point, we realize that endless punishment doesn’t do any more good. We relent and let them go out to play when we decide they’ve “learned their lesson.” It’s just the opposite for criminals: we keep them in prison far longer than it takes to get them to “learn their lesson.”
—Some people say: if they’re behind bars it keeps criminals off the streets. That is a great point if the criminal is truly dangerous. About half the people in prison now are there for non-violent offenses. Is this really helping in our fight against crime?
—The author takes us through some of the new, specialty courts that are working great. An good example is “drug court.” Instead of throwing drug offenders in jail for years, many states use a “drug court.” The defendant is put on probation and closely monitored through treatment and rehab until they are cured and can be productive again. Often, if they’re successful on probation, they won’t even get a permanent felony record.
In our fight against crime, we are seeing several success stories. This is just one of them.
